Fueling Your Coding Mojo

Buckle up, fellow PHP enthusiast! We're loading up the rocket fuel for your coding adventures...

Popular Searches:

Can expressions have side effects in PHP?

Hi there fellow PHP developers!

I've been working on a PHP project and came across a concept that I find a bit confusing. I have been reading about expressions in PHP, and I've read that expressions are usually expected to be free of side effects. However, I've also heard that in some cases expressions can indeed have side effects.

Now, I'm scratching my head trying to understand if this is true or not. Can expressions in PHP have side effects? I'd love to hear your thoughts and get some clarification on this matter. Additionally, if you could provide some examples to illustrate when expressions might have side effects, that would be super helpful.

Looking forward to your insights!

All Replies


Hey folks,

I thought I'd share my own experiences with expressions and side effects in PHP. In my practice, I've learned that while expressions are generally expected to be side-effect-free, there are instances where they can indeed produce side effects.

One example I've encountered involves using the short-circuit operators `&&` and `||`. These operators evaluate expressions in a specific order and stop evaluating once the result can be determined. However, this behavior can have side effects when the expressions themselves contain side effects, such as function calls with side effects.

Additionally, some built-in PHP functions may exhibit unexpected side effects when used within expressions. For instance, the `array_shift()` function both returns the first element of an array and modifies the array by removing that element. So, using `array_shift()` within an expression can alter the state of the original array unexpectedly.

It's worth noting that relying on side effects within expressions can make code less predictable and harder to reason about. Therefore, it's generally considered a good practice to minimize or avoid side effects within expressions whenever possible.

Based on my personal experience, I recommend being cautious when using expressions with built-in functions or operators that can potentially trigger side effects. Understanding the behavior of these functions or operators thoroughly can help write more reliable and maintainable code.

If you have any further questions or need clarity, feel free to ask. Happy coding, everyone!


Hey there!

From my personal experience with PHP, I can confirm that expressions in PHP can indeed have side effects. Although expressions are generally expected to be free of side effects and focus on returning a value without modifying any state, there are situations where side effects can occur.

For example, consider the use of functions like `echo` or `print` within an expression. These are commonly used to output data directly to the browser, but they do have side effects by altering the output buffer and sending data to the client. Another example is using the `++` or `--` increment or decrement operators within an expression, which modify the value of the variable being operated on.

In addition, certain built-in functions or methods can have side effects. For instance, functions like `unset()` or `array_pop()` directly modify the input data, impacting its original state.

It's important to keep in mind that while expressions in PHP can have side effects, it may not always be desirable or maintainable to have them. Striving for side-effect-free expressions can often lead to cleaner code and easier debugging. However, in certain cases, side effects within expressions can be useful and necessary.

I hope this sheds some light on the topic based on my personal experience. Let me know if you have any further questions or need more clarification!


Hey everyone!

In my PHP journey, I've encountered scenarios where expressions do have side effects. While it's generally preferred to maintain expressions without side effects, there are cases where side effects can't be avoided easily.

One instance where I've come across side effects within expressions is when using the assignment operator (`=`) within an expression. This can have unintended consequences and modify the value of variables being assigned. For example, consider the expression `$result = $someVar = someFunction()`. Here, the value returned by `someFunction()` is assigned to both `$result` and `$someVar`, potentially altering their values.

Similarly, certain array operations like merging or modifying arrays can have side effects when used within expressions. For instance, using operators like `+=` or `array_merge()` within an expression can lead to changes in the original arrays.

It's crucial to be aware of such cases where expressions might have side effects, as they can lead to unexpected behavior and make code harder to understand and debug. In general, it's a good practice to separate side-effect-free expressions from statements that intentionally modify state or perform actions.

Based on my personal experience, I recommend being cautious while using expressions with potential side effects. Strive for code that is readable, maintainable, and minimizes surprises caused by unintended alterations.

Feel free to ask if you want any further clarification or have more questions. Happy coding!

New to LearnPHP.org Community?

Join the community